"Thanks to the social security system in America which provides a worry-free life to my mother, [it] in turn relieves my burden to support my mom's living... In China, there is no social security or welfare for the elders. It is one of the big reasons that the Chinese children have a stronger sense
of responsibility for their parents." -- Mom
I've been meaning to write about social support and the Chinese for a while. I became interested in this subject while doing research for my senior thesis, as I tried to understand the effects of China's diminishing social support systems following economic reforms in 1978. The economist Amartya Sen argues that the Chinese preference for sons is primarily a socioeconomic one. Basically, many Chinese turn towards their families to provide adequate social support, particularly in old age. Because of traditions of patrilineal marriage, daughters are "given" in marriage and live with their in-laws. Sons stay "in" the family and are expected to provide care for their parents.
It's easy to see why sons are favored when there is little state support for the elderly. Most Chinese, both in and out of Chinese, seem to be largely apolitical, and rarely use politics to try and solve social problems (in marked contrast to most Latin American countries, for instance). And because most Chinese do not receive -- nor expect -- support from the state, they often turn toward their extended families for support.
Although the research has been out for a couple years at this point, the New York Times just published an article about gender bias even among overseas Chinese in the U.S.
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/15/nyregion/15babies.html
Showing posts with label Gender. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gender. Show all posts
Monday, June 22, 2009
Saturday, June 13, 2009
A mosque in Georgetown
At the end of the day today, I somehow found myself in the main mosque in Georgetown. There seem to be several small mosques around town, although given the multi-ethnic and multi-religious nature of Malaysia, none seem to dominate the town's architectural landscape as a church does in Latin America or a mosque in the Middle East. Hindu temples, Buddhist temples, Chinese ancestral temples, Anglican churches, and mosques are scattered around the town (Okay, no synagogues, but oddly enough there is a street called "Lebuh (Street) Katz").
I got into a conversation with the security guard and what appeared to be the mosque's PR guy. To make a long conversation less long, he seemed to say that Islam was very similar to Christianity and Judaism (assuming I came from a Judeo-Christian background), albeit a more pure, less adulterated religion that has avoided the corruption that comes with institutionalization and cultural adaptation . On the other hand, when the subject of gender equality came up, he admitted that what Muslim societies often practice isn't what Islam actually says. No surprises there. I did want to ask him, but didn't get the chance, why during prayer time all the women were off in a little cordoned-off room, whereas the men got to pray in the main prayer area. Separate, and certainly not equal.
I should say, though, that I am always impressed by the intense devotion of Muslims. Muslims are supposed to pray five times a day, and visitors to Muslim societies can attest to the (sometimes deafening) frequent calls to prayer, and the subsequent emptying of streets. The centrality of prayer, I think, sets Islam apart from the way most other religions are practiced.
On the subject of institutionalized religion, I remember reading something by some guy who practiced Sufism, a kind of mysticized Islam. I think the article was actually in reference to esoteric Christianity, but I'm getting off topic. The point was the guy said that mystics have always been persecuted, because they show that people don't need institutions (the Catholic church, for instance) to connect with God or higher powers.



I got into a conversation with the security guard and what appeared to be the mosque's PR guy. To make a long conversation less long, he seemed to say that Islam was very similar to Christianity and Judaism (assuming I came from a Judeo-Christian background), albeit a more pure, less adulterated religion that has avoided the corruption that comes with institutionalization and cultural adaptation . On the other hand, when the subject of gender equality came up, he admitted that what Muslim societies often practice isn't what Islam actually says. No surprises there. I did want to ask him, but didn't get the chance, why during prayer time all the women were off in a little cordoned-off room, whereas the men got to pray in the main prayer area. Separate, and certainly not equal.
I should say, though, that I am always impressed by the intense devotion of Muslims. Muslims are supposed to pray five times a day, and visitors to Muslim societies can attest to the (sometimes deafening) frequent calls to prayer, and the subsequent emptying of streets. The centrality of prayer, I think, sets Islam apart from the way most other religions are practiced.
On the subject of institutionalized religion, I remember reading something by some guy who practiced Sufism, a kind of mysticized Islam. I think the article was actually in reference to esoteric Christianity, but I'm getting off topic. The point was the guy said that mystics have always been persecuted, because they show that people don't need institutions (the Catholic church, for instance) to connect with God or higher powers.

Saturday, January 3, 2009
Observations of Italy's "Centri Sociali" during New Year's
January 1, 2009 marks the midpoint of my fellowship, and of course, a new year. The Chinese New Year doesn't start until January 26, when Chinese communities will welcome the Year of the Ox -- my year -- which means I'm turning twenty-four this year. Aside from being vaguely frightening at the thought of turning twenty-four, I'm also supposed to be watching my back this year, according to a friend from the Buddhist temple in Sao Paulo. Apparently one is more prone to bad luck during when the Zodiac revolves to their year (For those unfamiliar with the Chinese zodiac, the zodiac revolves around a twelve year cycle. I was born in 1985 in the year of the Ox; 1997, 2009, 2021 are thus also years of the Ox ... or oxen?).
But what I want to talk about is how I spent my New Year's Eve at a Centri Sociale, yes, a "social center," here in Milan.
I can't remember where I first read about Italy's Centri Sociali, which are basically squatted warehouses and other unused urban sites, started by students and other left-leaning Italians. I went to the biggest Centri Sociale in Milan, Leon Cavallo, currently located at Via Watteau, 7. Apparently, the center moves every few years as city authorities arrive to kick out the squatters. I'm sure the police know about Leon Cavallo's current location -- they make no secret about it -- but like the "illegal" favelas in Brazil's cities, it's probably more hassle to kick out the social centers than to just leave them be if they're not causing any trouble. As far as I could tell, the social center used to be some sort of warehouse and included a few smaller buildings in a courtyard. The buildings reminded me vaguely of art district 798 in Beijing -- although the usage of the buildings was quite different. And because the center makes little effort to comply with the law, basically everyone was smoking inside (smoking inside is illegal in Milan).
The center offers free language classes to Milan's many immigrants; it also pushes an agenda for greater social integration of Milan's immigrant communities. Indeed, one of the themes of the New Year's Party was a "new year free of racism." The center also includes a kitchen with cheap and delicious food, as well as pretty fantastic bookstore. Of course, one of the main focuses of the social center is to offer social events that provide a welcome respite from Milan's otherwise elitist social scene -- offering free or cheap concerts, movie screenings -- and is apparently the birthplace of Italian hip-hop (I can't say, however, whether or not this is a worthy distinction).
When midnight struck, there was no anticipatory count-down or ball-drop -- the music simply went on. Okay, a few people threw some firecrackers in the courtyard. But I suppose the party was only getting started: the hours were officially 11 pm to 9 am or something insane like that. The place featured four rooms with different music in each room, although the largest room was devoted, regrettably, to electronic music.
The demographic at the Center was very strange, and I spent most of the night speculating on why the Center drew the crowd. I'd say the Center was probably evenly divided among white Italians, Arab immigrants (I think mostly from Egypt), and African immigrants (mostly from various West African countries). But whereas the white Italians were more or less evenly divided among males and females, the Arab and African attendees were exclusively male, except maybe one or two Arab girls I saw. This meant the whole male to female ratio was probably about 10:1. Also absent were south Asians (Sri Lankans, Indians, Bangladeshis...) and Chinese immigrants. As a result, I seemed to get a lot of unwanted attention among the Arab attendees, for whatever reason, the African and white attendees didn't seem to give me any unusual attention.
What I found most strange was the lack of Arab and African females at the place. Okay, there were essentially no south Asians or east Asians, but that I could more or less comprehend. But why were there Arab and African people, but only males?
Milan's large immigrant community is relatively recent, so I'd guess the majority of ethnic minorities are first-generation immigrants, with a few exceptions. First-generation immigrants generally draw heavily upon value systems from their country of origin. I began to think that perhaps engaging in public social life is probably frowned upon for many women in the developing world, and this prejudice is carried over (and in some cases, even worsened) during emigration. Perhaps immigrant families are wary of exposing their daughters in unknown social environments, where social values and gender norms are unknown quantities. Patriarchal protection is unnecessary for male immigrants, who are probably curious to explore the contours of gender relations in their adopted country.
I used to think that preventing women from engaging in public life -- whether through social life or income-earning work -- was the principle factor that contributed toward gender inequality. Although I still believe that engagement in public life is critical toward greater gender equality, my experiences in Chinese culture suggests that the picture is much more complicated. For instance, in one Chinese immigrant family I met in South America, both the father and the son did not work, whereas both the mother and daughter worked full shifts everyday. Apparently, certain work is considered "fit" for women, mostly low-paying labor-intensive work, whereas men are expected to fulfill higher-paying, more "honorable" work positions. For the father of that family, it was probably more honorable to remain unemployed than to do "woman's work." The son told me he did not to do low-paying labor, and that was okay.
So, back to the Centri Sociali. The social aims of the Center are undoubtedly noble. But who is actually showing up to the Center? Or rather, who isn't showing up, and why not?
But what I want to talk about is how I spent my New Year's Eve at a Centri Sociale, yes, a "social center," here in Milan.
I can't remember where I first read about Italy's Centri Sociali, which are basically squatted warehouses and other unused urban sites, started by students and other left-leaning Italians. I went to the biggest Centri Sociale in Milan, Leon Cavallo, currently located at Via Watteau, 7. Apparently, the center moves every few years as city authorities arrive to kick out the squatters. I'm sure the police know about Leon Cavallo's current location -- they make no secret about it -- but like the "illegal" favelas in Brazil's cities, it's probably more hassle to kick out the social centers than to just leave them be if they're not causing any trouble. As far as I could tell, the social center used to be some sort of warehouse and included a few smaller buildings in a courtyard. The buildings reminded me vaguely of art district 798 in Beijing -- although the usage of the buildings was quite different. And because the center makes little effort to comply with the law, basically everyone was smoking inside (smoking inside is illegal in Milan).
The center offers free language classes to Milan's many immigrants; it also pushes an agenda for greater social integration of Milan's immigrant communities. Indeed, one of the themes of the New Year's Party was a "new year free of racism." The center also includes a kitchen with cheap and delicious food, as well as pretty fantastic bookstore. Of course, one of the main focuses of the social center is to offer social events that provide a welcome respite from Milan's otherwise elitist social scene -- offering free or cheap concerts, movie screenings -- and is apparently the birthplace of Italian hip-hop (I can't say, however, whether or not this is a worthy distinction).
When midnight struck, there was no anticipatory count-down or ball-drop -- the music simply went on. Okay, a few people threw some firecrackers in the courtyard. But I suppose the party was only getting started: the hours were officially 11 pm to 9 am or something insane like that. The place featured four rooms with different music in each room, although the largest room was devoted, regrettably, to electronic music.
The demographic at the Center was very strange, and I spent most of the night speculating on why the Center drew the crowd. I'd say the Center was probably evenly divided among white Italians, Arab immigrants (I think mostly from Egypt), and African immigrants (mostly from various West African countries). But whereas the white Italians were more or less evenly divided among males and females, the Arab and African attendees were exclusively male, except maybe one or two Arab girls I saw. This meant the whole male to female ratio was probably about 10:1. Also absent were south Asians (Sri Lankans, Indians, Bangladeshis...) and Chinese immigrants. As a result, I seemed to get a lot of unwanted attention among the Arab attendees, for whatever reason, the African and white attendees didn't seem to give me any unusual attention.
What I found most strange was the lack of Arab and African females at the place. Okay, there were essentially no south Asians or east Asians, but that I could more or less comprehend. But why were there Arab and African people, but only males?
Milan's large immigrant community is relatively recent, so I'd guess the majority of ethnic minorities are first-generation immigrants, with a few exceptions. First-generation immigrants generally draw heavily upon value systems from their country of origin. I began to think that perhaps engaging in public social life is probably frowned upon for many women in the developing world, and this prejudice is carried over (and in some cases, even worsened) during emigration. Perhaps immigrant families are wary of exposing their daughters in unknown social environments, where social values and gender norms are unknown quantities. Patriarchal protection is unnecessary for male immigrants, who are probably curious to explore the contours of gender relations in their adopted country.
I used to think that preventing women from engaging in public life -- whether through social life or income-earning work -- was the principle factor that contributed toward gender inequality. Although I still believe that engagement in public life is critical toward greater gender equality, my experiences in Chinese culture suggests that the picture is much more complicated. For instance, in one Chinese immigrant family I met in South America, both the father and the son did not work, whereas both the mother and daughter worked full shifts everyday. Apparently, certain work is considered "fit" for women, mostly low-paying labor-intensive work, whereas men are expected to fulfill higher-paying, more "honorable" work positions. For the father of that family, it was probably more honorable to remain unemployed than to do "woman's work." The son told me he did not to do low-paying labor, and that was okay.
So, back to the Centri Sociali. The social aims of the Center are undoubtedly noble. But who is actually showing up to the Center? Or rather, who isn't showing up, and why not?
Wednesday, October 1, 2008
Brazil... photography... China... gender...
I normally don't post about photography-related things, but since I spend a lot of time taking photos and looking at photos, I'm going to make an exception now for a really cool photography exhibition. French photographer JR , has an awesome public photography exhibition in Rio de Janiero on women. Yes, he's too cool to have a real name, apparently he's an "underground" photographer that first gained fame (or notoriety?) through his illegal exhibition of mural-sized photos in public spaces; later, his stuff became recognized and received positive reviews. The exhibition displays blown up portraits of women in Brazil's notorious favelas -- slums or shantytowns within Brazil's big cities such as Rio and Sao Paulo. Favelas are infamous for their high murder rates, drugs, and poverty.
Although I haven't seen any of JR's stuff in person, it is really impressive; it is socially-conscious photography that is made even more impressive by its public, mural-sized exhibition. The first stuff that I saw was a series of portraits that he took following last year's riots in Paris's banlieues, which were then exhibited as large mural-sized photographs around Paris. You can see an awesome short film on the project, I highly recommend viewing it on youtube here:
The 28 millimeter project
I hope the exhibit might still be up in Rio when I make it to Brazil. You can see photos of the exhibit here at the photography website Lensculture.
Here's a photo of the favela at night:
On gender
On a similar note, I first became fascinated with gender equality in college in my development-related classes, and reading about the Nobel Prize-winning Grameen bank's microlending to Bangladeshi women. The Grameen bank famously found that women were much better clients for loans -- they used money more wisely, and also contributed to many beneficial externalities (better child health, education, etc...).
A woman's position in society is not only a good index of a country's economic development, but also a good index of it's social development as well. My own thesis work also examined gender equality initiatives under China's communist government, which found a positive relationship between political emphasis on gender equality and improved child health. But I was also disturbed by the phenomenon of China's missing women: the phenomenon that since economic reforms began in 1979, the sex ratio of China's population has become far more biased toward males. For instance, in most normal populations the sex ratio at birth is about 105 to 107 male births for every female births. In China this has increased to about 116 male births, and this bias is pervasive in other cohorts as well.
In fact, many Asian and Muslim countries have this problem, including economically developed countries such as Japan, Korea, and Taiwan. The most basic explanation is that in these countries male children are more valued than female children, and hence practices such as sex-selective abortion, female infanticide, and selective neglect has lead to imbalanced sex ratios within these societies. Strangely, Latin America doesn't seem to have the problem of sex ratio, despite being an infamously "macho" society. I would hypothesize that this might be partially due to the cultural and religious abhorrence toward abortion; of course, this doesn't explain everything. Anyways, this is a subject that I have found fascinating, and I still do not fully understand the underlying reasons.
Another phenomenon is that of China's extraordinary rate of female suicides: in most countries, the male to female suicide rate is about 4:1, in China, it is 1:1. What is driving China's women to commit suicide at such an alarming rate? Are the pressures China's women (or for that matter, East Asian women) face similar to those among Chinese women abroad?
Consider this an introduction to a future post about my observations on gender within Paraguay's Chinese community.
Although I haven't seen any of JR's stuff in person, it is really impressive; it is socially-conscious photography that is made even more impressive by its public, mural-sized exhibition. The first stuff that I saw was a series of portraits that he took following last year's riots in Paris's banlieues, which were then exhibited as large mural-sized photographs around Paris. You can see an awesome short film on the project, I highly recommend viewing it on youtube here:
The 28 millimeter project
I hope the exhibit might still be up in Rio when I make it to Brazil. You can see photos of the exhibit here at the photography website Lensculture.
Here's a photo of the favela at night:
On a similar note, I first became fascinated with gender equality in college in my development-related classes, and reading about the Nobel Prize-winning Grameen bank's microlending to Bangladeshi women. The Grameen bank famously found that women were much better clients for loans -- they used money more wisely, and also contributed to many beneficial externalities (better child health, education, etc...).
A woman's position in society is not only a good index of a country's economic development, but also a good index of it's social development as well. My own thesis work also examined gender equality initiatives under China's communist government, which found a positive relationship between political emphasis on gender equality and improved child health. But I was also disturbed by the phenomenon of China's missing women: the phenomenon that since economic reforms began in 1979, the sex ratio of China's population has become far more biased toward males. For instance, in most normal populations the sex ratio at birth is about 105 to 107 male births for every female births. In China this has increased to about 116 male births, and this bias is pervasive in other cohorts as well.
In fact, many Asian and Muslim countries have this problem, including economically developed countries such as Japan, Korea, and Taiwan. The most basic explanation is that in these countries male children are more valued than female children, and hence practices such as sex-selective abortion, female infanticide, and selective neglect has lead to imbalanced sex ratios within these societies. Strangely, Latin America doesn't seem to have the problem of sex ratio, despite being an infamously "macho" society. I would hypothesize that this might be partially due to the cultural and religious abhorrence toward abortion; of course, this doesn't explain everything. Anyways, this is a subject that I have found fascinating, and I still do not fully understand the underlying reasons.
Another phenomenon is that of China's extraordinary rate of female suicides: in most countries, the male to female suicide rate is about 4:1, in China, it is 1:1. What is driving China's women to commit suicide at such an alarming rate? Are the pressures China's women (or for that matter, East Asian women) face similar to those among Chinese women abroad?
Consider this an introduction to a future post about my observations on gender within Paraguay's Chinese community.
Labels:
Brazil,
Chinese culture,
Economy,
Gender,
Paraguay,
photography
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)